I have a weakness for animal comics.
This should surprise absolutely nobody.
Give me a creature with a strong personality and I'm interested.
Give that creature a group of other creatures who don't quite know what they're all supposed to be doing and I'm probably staying.
But after spending a ridiculous amount of time drawing animals myself, I've realised that the best animal comics aren't necessarily the ones with the cutest characters.
Here are seven things I look for in a good animal webcomic.
1. The Animals Feel Like Animals
This is probably my biggest one.
An animal character doesn't have to behave exactly like a real animal all the time. It's fiction. We are allowed to have some fun.
But I like being able to recognise the creature underneath the character.
A horse should have the physical presence of a horse.
A bird should move like a bird.
A cat shouldn't suddenly have the body language of a golden retriever just because the artist needed a particular expression (unless that's like... literally a plot in the story. I'd read a comic about cats turning into dogs!)
Those little details make fictional creatures feel convincing.
2. Every Character Has a Personality
If I can swap one animal for another and nothing about the story changes, something is missing.
I want to know why this character is in the story.
What makes them different?
What annoys them?
What makes them happy?
What are they afraid of?
What do they do when things go wrong?
The answers don't have to be complicated. But even animals that don't speak like humans have motivations, habits, moods…
Sometimes "this character is extremely food motivated" is plenty to get started.
3. The Relationships Matter
A good group of characters shouldn't just exist in the same panel.
They should affect one another.
One character should make another character angry.
Someone should make somebody else laugh (even if it's at their expense).
Someone should bring out a side of another character that we wouldn't see otherwise, which is really important in animal comics because the relationships can be communicated through body language as much as dialogue.
Who sits beside who?
Who follows who?
Who gets protective?
Who gets left behind?
Those things can tell a story.
4. There's a Reason to Keep Reading
I don't necessarily need a giant cliffhanger at the end of every update.
But I do need a question:
What happens next?
- Why did that character do that?
- Where are they going?
- What is that weird thing in the background?
- Is that horse about to kick somebody?
…Okay, that last one might be specific to my comic.
The point is that a good webcomic gives you a reason to come back.
5. The Art Has a Point of View
I'm not looking for perfect art.
I'm looking for interesting art.
A distinctive way of drawing faces, an unusual approach to colour, a particular way of exaggerating expressions, a strange little detail that makes the artist's work immediately recognisable.
Independent comics have an advantage here because creators aren't necessarily trying to make everything look like everything else.
The quirks are often part of the appeal.
6. The World Feels Bigger Than the Page
This is especially important to me in fantasy comics.
I want to feel like the characters exist when they're not on the page.
Where did they come from?
What happened before the story started?
What does their world look like outside this particular scene?
You don't have to explain everything. In fact, please don't explain everything. Give me enough to become curious.
7. I Care About Somebody
This is the big one.
I don't need every character to be nice, to make good decisions or even be likeable, but I need to care what happens to somebody.
Maybe I care because they're funny.
They're irritating but fascinating.
They're vulnerable.
I see something of myself in them.
Maybe I just really want to know whether they're going to survive their own terrible decision.
That's enough.
What I Tried to Do With The Golden Troupe
These are some of the things I think about when I'm making The Golden Troupe.
The animals are animals.
The characters have very different personalities.
Their relationships matter.
And the story is ultimately about what happens when a group of very different creatures finds a way to belong together.
I don't expect every reader to connect with every character.
In fact, I'm perfectly happy if you have a favourite and a character you can't stand.
That's part of the fun.
I suspect everybody is going to have an opinion about Aspa.
If you'd like to find out who you end up siding with, you can meet the Troupe and start reading here.
And if you want to follow the comic as I work on what's next, you can join the Troupe here.
Just don't tell Qui I said he wasn't the favourite.
He already has enough of an ego.




